Philosopher

Protagoras

c. 490 – c. 420 BCE

Also known as Protagoras of Abdera

The first to call himself a sophist, he taught argument for a fee, held that "man is the measure of all things", and said he could not know whether the gods exist.

Dark painting of a man in rough clothes kneeling to tie a bundle of firewood, watched by an old bearded man and others
Salvator Rosa, Democritus and Protagoras, 1663–64. It shows the legend that Democritus found the young Protagoras working as a porter; the story is almost certainly untrue.Salvator Rosa · Public domain · See the original

Of all things the measure is man: of those that are, that they are; and of those that are not, that they are not.

Truth, DK 80B1, translation as quoted by Mauro Bonazzi

Protagoras was born in Abdera in Thrace, probably in the 490s BCE, and travelled the Greek world as a paid teacher, becoming famous and rich; Plato credits him with being the first to adopt the title of sophist openly. He stayed in Athens at least twice and knew Pericles, who in 444 entrusted him with writing laws for the new colony of Thurii in southern Italy. Later stories say that he was tried for impiety, that his books were burned and that he drowned fleeing Athens, but these are doubtful: Plato writes as if he died old and respected, at about seventy.

Fewer than ten genuine fragments survive, so his thought is known mostly through Plato, who gave him a dialogue of his own, the Protagoras, and examined his “measure” doctrine at length in the Theaetetus, and through Aristotle and Sextus Empiricus. Democritus, a younger man from the same city, argued that the doctrine undermines itself, and Plato and Aristotle developed the objection. His separation of justice from the will of the gods, and his confidence that ordinary citizens can judge political questions, have been read as a theoretical basis for Athenian democracy.

Key ideas

Man the measure
His book Truth began: “Of all things the measure is man”. Plato read it as saying that things are for each person as they appear to that person, so that if the wind feels cold to me, it is cold for me. It is often taken as the first statement of relativism.
Not knowing about the gods
He wrote that he could know neither whether the gods exist nor what they are like, because the matter is obscure and life is short. Hostile sources called this atheism, but it is a claim about what we can know, which makes him the first known agnostic.
Justice as a shared human skill
In the myth Plato gives him, Zeus hands out justice and a sense of shame to everyone, not to a few experts. Laws are human decisions that suit a city’s circumstances and can change, and every citizen has a share in political skill, an outlook well suited to democracy.
Teaching argument
He trained pupils to argue both sides of a question, to attack opposing theses and to use language correctly, from grammar to the consistency of a poem. He is said to have spent a whole day with Pericles debating who was to blame when a javelin killed an athlete.
Tradition
Western
Region
Abdera, Thrace; Athens

Influences

Where these links come from
  • Democritus argued against Protagoras. Source: Mauro Bonazzi, Protagoras, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  • Plato argued against Protagoras. Source: Mauro Bonazzi, Protagoras, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Key works

  • Truth (Alētheia)
  • On the Gods
  • Opposing Arguments (Antilogiai)

Sources

  1. Mauro Bonazzi, Protagoras, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy